Skip to Content

'Returnaholics' cost retailers billions of dollars a year

Text SizeAAA

Filed under: Shopping, Fraud, Consumer Ally, Economizer

If you've noticed that returning items to stores isn't as easy as it used to be, rest assured: It isn't just you. Thanks to a growing number of people who are returning items they've used or never bought in the first place, retailers have been employing a variety of new techniques to stop so-called "returnaholics" and others from abusing the return process.

Last year, return fraud cost the retail industry an estimated $10 billion to $15 billion, according to the National Retail Federation. In fact, return fraud has become such a problem that it has sparked an industry-wide crackdown. Stores are using databases to identify serial returners.
"This kind of behavior escalates during economic downturns, when people don't have the cash to buy the things they want," said Mike Kraus, a retail expert for Allbusiness and CEO of the consultancy StoreTouch.

Being a "returnaholic" isn't so much a psychological issue as a financial one. Kraus said most people aren't serial returners because they like buying and returning items, but rather because they want to make a buck.

Have you ever bought an item to use knowing you would return it?
Yes, and I feel terrible about it.4485 (4.3%)
Yes, and what's wrong with that?9671 (9.4%)
No, that's wrong.89175 (86.3%)


One of the most widely-known schemes entails something that retailers call "wardrobing," which describes the act of purchasing clothes, wearing them and then returning them. Apparel (particularly special occasion clothes), electronics and tools are among the most commonly returned items after they've been used. Take, for example, a homeowner who needs a drill for one project, but doesn't want to shell out the cash to own a drill. They purchase the drill, leave the tags on, use it and bring it back when they're done.

Some returnaholics are even more bold. "One of our customers just identified a woman who was hitting them every single day," says Derek Rodner, a loss control expert and vice president of Agilence Inc., which sells software to help retailers identify repeat offenders and problem returners. "This woman would simply walk into the store, make note of the store manager's name from the sign at the customer service desk or hanging near the front of the store, go into the aisles and pick up several items and go right to the customer service desk and return them without a receipt. She would simply say that she called (using the name of the store manager) and he told her to bring the items back. This woman was hitting 27 of their 133 stores, two a day, and then she would repeat. She admitted to over $10,000 in return theft over the course of 90 days."

Even legitimate returns can cost a store. The store eats the original transaction fee if the purchase was made by credit card, for example. But it's those steal by returning an item for a refund or credit who are the biggest threat. "This is why many retailers have implemented complex software tools that monitor these returns and may eventually limit a customer from returning more items," Rodner said.

And some measures are less high-tech. To well defend against "wardrobing" some stores have started putting the tags in prominent places in the front of garments so they can't be easily tucked away. And, they require that clothes brought for return must still have the tags.
Subscribe to Walletpop

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 23)

Beau Brendler
Beau Brendler Filed under: Technology, Identity Theft, Consumer Ally

Warning: E-mails pretending to be from FedEx can wreak havoc

If your mailbox has been bombed the last couple of weeks by e-mails appearing to be from FedEx and claiming a package sent to you has gone undelivered, blame Zeus, king of criminal bots, for helping ...
Stella M. Chavez
Stella M. Chavez Filed under: Home, Fraud, Consumer Ally

American Shingle files for bankruptcy

American Shingle and Siding, Inc., the Atlanta-based roofing company accused of defrauding hundreds of homeowners around the country, has filed for bankruptcy, owing creditors $10 million-$50 million, ...
Martha C. White
Martha C. White Filed under: Credit, Consumer Ally, Credit Reports, Credit Cards

Freeze your credit? It's one way to cut out the con artist

Many Americans these days are understandably worried about the prospect of identity theft in which a scammer opens up a credit card or other loan in the victim's name, runs up all kinds of charges and ...
Gergana Koleva
Gergana Koleva Filed under: Fraud, Consumer Ally, Personal Loans

FTC: Payday lender tried garnishing wages on unpaid 860% interest loans

A payday lender that charged 860% interest on loans and tried to get borrowers to accept wage garnishment if they couldn't pay them back has settled a Federal Trade Commision lawsuit. The FTC sued ...

Interest Rates

  • Current
  • +3.39%
  • +4.33%
  • +7.29%
  • +6.16%
  • +1.09%
  • Apr
  • +3.34%
  • +4.51%
  • 0.00%
  • 0.00%
  • +1.09%

Interest Rates Provided by Bankrate.com

Compare Rates in Your Area

Headlines from WalletPop Partners